News

1. Supreme Court agrees to decide legality of mandatory detention without bond hearings

What happened

The Supreme Court granted certiorari on October 1 to decide whether noncitizens who entered the U.S. without inspection, then lived in the interior for years before being detained, can be held in mandatory detention without any bond hearing. The Court will hear the government’s appeal in the case of Ricardo Aparecido Barbosa da Cunha, a man from Brazil who entered the U.S. in the mid-2000s.

The case turns on which of two INA provisions applies: Section 1225, covering “applicants for admission” and allowing no bond hearing, or Section 1226, covering noncitizens already in removal proceedings in the interior, which does allow a bond hearing before an immigration judge. The administration has argued since mid-2025 that anyone who ever entered without inspection remains an “applicant for admission” under Section 1225 no matter how long they have lived in the country.

This resolves, for the circuits that have ruled, a question already covered in the September roundup: nine federal appeals courts, most recently the Fourth Circuit, have rejected the government’s position, while the Fifth and Eighth Circuits have sided with it. The Court’s ruling is expected by the end of June 2027.

Detention numbers have risen sharply under the policy being challenged, from just under 38,000 at the end of the prior administration to more than 65,000 this past summer, according to CNN.

What does this mean?

For attorneys: continue raising Section 1226 bond hearing arguments for long-term resident clients detained after an entry without inspection, especially within the Fourth Circuit and the other eight circuits that have already ruled against the government’s position. The circuit split remains the controlling law in each circuit until the Supreme Court rules, likely by June 2027.

For noncitizens: whether you get a bond hearing may still depend heavily on which circuit you are detained in, at least until the Supreme Court decides this case. This remains genuinely unsettled nationally.

Bigger picture: this is the Supreme Court’s most direct engagement yet with the legal theory underlying the sharp rise in detention numbers this year. A ruling for the government would lock in mandatory detention nationwide for a very large population of long-term residents; a ruling against it would restore bond hearings nationwide for that same group.

Sources:

2. Judge halts DHS policy that stopped collecting biometrics from detained immigration applicants

What happened

U.S. District Judge Amir H. Ali (D.D.C.) issued an order October 7 in J.Z. et al. v. U.S. Department of Homeland Security et al., staying a DHS policy, announced in December 2025, under which DHS generally stopped collecting biometrics (fingerprints, photographs) from detained noncitizens with pending USCIS benefit applications, including unaccompanied children. USCIS had cited deterring frivolous claims as one reason for the policy.

Before the policy, ICE was responsible for helping detained applicants complete biometrics, including transporting them to appointments. USCIS generally cannot approve a benefit application without biometrics on file, so detained applicants were left unable to complete a step their own case required, risking their applications being treated as abandoned.

The government argued detainees could ask ICE to collect their information voluntarily, or pursue their applications after being deported. Judge Ali rejected this, finding DHS had not adequately explained the policy change or its effect on detained applicants, and noting that ICE has in fact collected biometrics before, but only in response to litigation or a court order.

The stay applies nationwide and restores DHS’s prior responsibility for collecting biometrics from this group while the underlying lawsuit continues. Ali declined to go further and grant a full preliminary injunction. As of this writing, the stay remains in effect. Plaintiffs are represented by Democracy Forward, the National Immigration Project, and the National Immigrant Justice Center, who described the policy in a joint statement as “an impossible trap: requiring individuals to provide biometrics to apply for legal protections, refusing to collect them, and then denying their applications for non-compliance.”

What does this mean?

For attorneys: any detained client with a pending USCIS application that has stalled for lack of a biometrics appointment should now have a stronger basis to push for one, and to document ICE’s obligation to facilitate it. Continue monitoring the case for any further order, since the stay could be narrowed, expanded, or made permanent as the litigation proceeds.

For detained applicants: this does not grant anyone a visa, status, or release from detention on its own, but it restores the government’s responsibility to collect the biometrics your application needs to move forward, rather than leaving that step entirely on you while detained.

Bigger picture: Democracy Forward described the prior policy as trapping people into providing biometrics to seek protection while DHS refused to collect them, then denying applications for noncompliance. This is part of a broader pattern already tracked in this roundup, of detained people losing practical access to the very legal processes still technically available to them.

Sources:

3. DOL suspends green card labor certification for Microsoft, Adobe, and six outsourcing firms

What happened

The Department of Labor suspended PERM labor certification processing on October 8 for eight companies: Microsoft, Adobe, and the IT services firms Cognizant, Infosys, Tata, Wipro, HCL, and Capgemini. PERM is the labor certification step that normally comes before an employer can sponsor a worker for an employment-based green card. Vice President JD Vance announced the action, accusing Microsoft specifically of laying off 6,000 American workers last year while obtaining 6,300 H-1B visas and nearly 3,000 green cards for foreign workers in the same period. The announcement came hours before Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella was scheduled to receive the National Medal of Technology and Innovation from Trump at a separate event.

This is not a ban on H-1B status itself and does not cancel anyone’s current status. It freezes PERM applications for these companies going forward, affecting workers trying to extend status past the six-year H-1B limit, keep a spouse’s work authorization tied to a pending green card case, or otherwise move toward permanent residency through one of these employers.

None of the eight companies has been charged with fraud. DOL described this as an enforcement tool it has used before at smaller scale, including a 180-day PERM suspension for Cloudera in May and for Cognizant again in September, now applied to much larger, more prominent employers.

Microsoft publicly disputed the administration’s framing, saying in a statement that about 80% of its roughly 6,000 H-1B filings last year were to extend or change the status of existing employees, not to hire new workers, and that its H-1B filings were unrelated to its layoffs.

What does this mean?

For attorneys: any client whose green card case depends on PERM sponsorship from one of these eight employers should be told now that the case has stopped moving, with no announced end date. Review each affected client’s H-1B status expiration and any six-year cap extension that depended on a pending PERM filing, since that extension path may no longer be available while the suspension lasts.

For H-1B workers at these companies and their spouses: a pending green card case through one of these employers is frozen, not necessarily canceled, but there is no timeline for when processing will resume. A spouse’s work authorization tied to that pending case may also be affected. Confirm your own status expiration date and talk to an attorney about other options well before that date.

Bigger picture: this is a significant escalation of a tool DOL had previously used only on individual companies at a time, now applied simultaneously to Microsoft, Adobe, and six major outsourcing firms together, several of the largest employers of H-1B workers in the country. It signals the administration is willing to use PERM suspension as a visible enforcement lever against major, well-known companies, not just smaller firms already under investigation.

Sources:

4. Broad coalition sues USCIS over two policies making green card denials easier

What happened

On October 5, a coalition of labor unions, university faculty groups, a Miami-based legal aid organization, and six individual green card applicants sued DHS and USCIS in federal court in Boston, challenging two USCIS policy memos issued this year.

The first, a May 2026 memo, directs officers to treat an applicant’s choice to seek a green card through adjustment of status inside the U.S., rather than leaving to consular process abroad, as a negative discretionary factor. It characterizes adjustment of status as an “extraordinary departure” from normal procedure, and requires applicants to show “unusual or even outstanding” positive factors to overcome that negative mark.

The second is the August 5 policy already covered in this roundup’s August edition, which gives USCIS officers broader authority to deny an application outright without first issuing a Request for Evidence or Notice of Intent to Deny. The lawsuit argues this policy applies retroactively to applications filed before it existed, when applicants had no reason to anticipate needing to submit extra evidence up front.

Plaintiffs argue both memos are arbitrary and capricious under the Administrative Procedure Act, and that the May memo also contradicts existing BIA precedent (Matter of Arai and similar decisions) on how discretion should be weighed. They are represented by Democracy Forward, the American Immigration Council, AILA, and Colombo & Hurd. Both policies remain in effect while the case proceeds, and no ruling had issued as of October 7.

What does this mean?

For attorneys: continue building the strongest possible discretionary record for any client adjusting status inside the U.S., since the May memo’s heightened standard remains in effect for now. For clients who filed before August 5 without anticipating this evidentiary standard, this lawsuit may eventually provide relief, but it does not change how a case should be prepared today.

For green card applicants adjusting status in the U.S.: these two policies are currently still in effect. Choosing to pursue your green card from inside the country, rather than leaving for consular processing, can still be held against you absent strong offsetting factors, and your application can still be denied without a chance to fix a missing document. Watch this case for any court order that changes that.

Bigger picture: this links two policies already covered separately in this roundup series (the August RFE and NOID change, and now this newly challenged May adjustment of status memo) into a single, broader legal challenge, arguing the combined effect of both memos is to push people who are otherwise eligible to stay and adjust status here into leaving the country instead, with all the family and job disruption that can cause.

Sources:

5. USCIS opens new asylum office in Charlotte

What happened

USCIS announced October 9 that it is opening a new asylum office in Charlotte, North Carolina, effective October 13. Asylum applicants residing in North Carolina or South Carolina, whether their case is already filed or still being prepared, now fall under this new office’s jurisdiction for affirmative asylum processing, including I-589 interviews. The office is located at 128 South Tryon Street, Suite 600, Charlotte, North Carolina 28202. It operates by appointment only and does not accept walk-ins.

Anyone scheduled for an asylum interview should carefully check their interview notice for the correct location, since USCIS noted this change does not automatically move every pending Carolinas case to Charlotte on its own.

What does this mean?

For attorneys: confirm the interview location on every notice for a Carolinas-based asylum client going forward rather than assuming an out-of-state office still has jurisdiction. This also means local clients should see shorter travel distances for interviews going forward, which may ease scheduling and preparation.

For asylum applicants in North Carolina and South Carolina: your case may now be handled out of Charlotte rather than a more distant office. Watch any interview notice closely for the specific address, and do not assume your case moves automatically just because the new office has opened.

Bigger picture: a dedicated local asylum office is a practical improvement for applicants in the Carolinas, cutting down on travel to more distant offices for what is often one of the most important interviews in an asylum case.

Sources:

6. DHS proposes $70,000 and $30,000 fees on schools for recommending F-1 students for OPT

What happened

DHS published a proposed rule October 8 that would require schools certified by the Student and Exchange Visitor Program to pay $70,000 before a Designated School Official enters a student’s first OPT recommendation in SEVIS, and $30,000 for each subsequent OPT recommendation, including a STEM OPT extension. A student who completes initial OPT and later gets a STEM extension could generate $100,000 in fees across both steps.

The fee is paid by the school, not the student or a specific employer, and is not tied to any one job. USCIS would not grant OPT work authorization until the school has paid the applicable fee. Changing employers within an already-authorized OPT period does not trigger a new fee.

DHS says the fees are meant to deter fraud and strengthen program oversight, and expects some schools to respond by becoming more selective about which students they recommend, or by steering students toward post-completion OPT only to generate the higher combined fee. DHS estimates the rule would affect roughly 2,478 schools and generate $8.4 to $16.5 billion annually.

This is not yet in effect. It is a proposed rule, not a final one. Public comments are due November 9, and comments on the related information collection are due December 7. If finalized as proposed, it would take effect 60 days after a final rule is published, and would not apply to OPT recommendations already issued before that date.

What does this mean?

For attorneys: advise university clients now that this fee, if finalized, would make recommending any student for OPT a significant financial decision for the school itself, separate from anything the student or employer pays. Watch the comment period and any changes between the proposed and final rule, since the fee structure could still change before taking effect.

For F-1 students and schools: nothing has changed yet. Current OPT and STEM OPT procedures remain in place while this is only a proposal. If finalized, expect schools to become more selective about recommending students for OPT given the cost involved.

Bigger picture: this follows the same playbook as the H-1B fee increases already covered in this roundup series, a large new fee justified as fraud prevention, this time aimed at the institution rather than the worker or employer. Combined with the H-1B fee proposals, this continues a broader pattern of adding substantial costs across nearly every step of employment-based immigration.

Sources:

7. DHS cuts refugees’ response time to fight status termination from 30 days to 10

What happened

DHS published an interim final rule October 14 that shortens, from 30 days to 10 days, the time a refugee has to respond to a Notice of Intent to Terminate their refugee status with evidence of continued eligibility. The rule took effect immediately upon publication, with no delay period, though DHS is separately accepting public comments on it for 30 days.

The rule applies only to termination of refugee status itself, not to asylum, humanitarian parole, Form I-220A status, lawful permanent residence, or citizenship. DHS estimates up to roughly 186,000 refugee cases admitted between fiscal years 2015 and 2025, who have not yet adjusted to a green card, could potentially be subject to this rule. The rule provides no administrative appeal of a termination decision.

DHS justified the change by citing an audit of refugee cases in Minnesota that found insufficient evidence in most files to establish eligibility, and by pointing to what it calls deficient refugee screening practices under the prior administration, including as part of an initiative called Operation PARRIS (Post-Admission Refugee Reverification and Integrity Strengthening).

Refugee resettlement organizations, including HIAS, Church World Service, Global Refuge, and World Relief, condemned the rule as eliminating meaningful due process, arguing 10 days is not enough time to retain a lawyer, gather documents, or prepare evidence, especially if a notice does not reach someone before the clock runs out. Refugee advocacy groups, represented by Democracy Forward, sued in federal court in Boston on October 26. On October 27, Judge Julia Kobick temporarily blocked the 10-day rule through November 6, preserving the existing 30-day period until a different judge can hear the case. The lawsuit also challenges other refugee policies, including the decision not to process green card applications for refugees admitted under the prior administration and a requirement to re-interview refugees who were already vetted. A USCIS spokesperson called the lawsuit a frivolous attempt to disrupt the administration’s immigration enforcement.

What does this mean?

For attorneys: any client who is a refugee and has not yet adjusted to permanent residence should be told now that a Notice of Intent to Terminate carries a far shorter response window than before, 10 days rather than 30. Build a response plan and gather key eligibility documents proactively for any client in this position, rather than waiting for a notice to arrive before starting that work.

For refugees who have not yet adjusted status: the 10-day rule is blocked only temporarily, through November 6, so the 30-day period applies for now but could change. A refugee who receives a Notice of Intent to Terminate refugee status should contact an attorney immediately and respond as early as possible, rather than relying on the longer period.

Bigger picture: this is a significant cut to due process for a group DHS itself estimates at roughly 186,000 people, with no administrative appeal available if status is terminated. It fits the broader pattern already tracked in this roundup series of compressed timelines, in mega master court hearings and now here, making it harder for people to exercise rights that still technically exist on paper.

Sources:

8. Ukraine and Sudan TPS holders retain protection as DHS again misses its own deadline

What happened

TPS designations for Ukraine and Sudan were set to expire October 19. DHS told reporters the day before that nationals of both countries enrolled in TPS will “retain protection,” including work authorization, while the agency says an announcement “will be made at the appropriate time.” As of this writing, no Federal Register notice extending or terminating either designation has been published.

This is the same pattern already covered in this roundup series with El Salvador’s TPS designation in September. Federal law requires DHS to publish a determination at least 60 days before a designation’s end date, a deadline that fell around August 20 for Ukraine and Sudan. When DHS misses that deadline, the statute automatically extends the designation for six months regardless of whether DHS ever announces it, the same automatic extension already confirmed for El Salvador.

Roughly 100,000 to 103,700 Ukrainian nationals and 1,800 to 6,800 Sudanese nationals hold TPS, depending on the source and whether the count reflects current holders or everyone who has ever registered. Ukraine was first designated for TPS in April 2022 following Russia’s invasion; Sudan’s designation dates to the late 1990s, tied to ongoing armed conflict.

This is the second time in two months the administration has let a TPS deadline pass without a published decision, after doing the same with El Salvador in September. The administration has moved to terminate TPS for numerous other countries, including Haiti, Venezuela, Somalia, Yemen, and Syria, so this reprieve for Ukraine and Sudan stands out from that broader pattern.

What does this mean?

For attorneys: as with El Salvador, advise Ukrainian and Sudanese TPS clients that their status has not lapsed. The automatic six-month extension applies by operation of law whether or not DHS ever issues a confirming notice. Continue tracking both designations for the eventual DHS announcement, and preserve the same statutory extension argument used for El Salvador if it becomes necessary.

For Ukrainian and Sudanese TPS holders: your status and work authorization continue for now, even though the scheduled end date has passed and DHS has not made a final announcement. Check the USCIS TPS page directly for updates, and do not make major decisions based on the original October 19 date alone.

Bigger picture: DHS has now missed its own statutory deadline at least three times this year, Lebanon, El Salvador, and now Ukraine and Sudan together, each time leaving affected communities and employers in uncertainty for weeks or months before any formal notice. Whether this is deliberate delay or genuine indecision, the practical effect is the same: real people living without a clear, published answer about their status.

Sources:

9. BIA ends presumption of continuance for pending U visa petitions

What happened

The BIA issued a precedent decision October 16 in Matter of L. Ramirez, 30 I&N Dec. 157 (BIA 2026), overruling Matter of Sanchez Sosa, 25 I&N Dec. 807 (BIA 2012). Under Sanchez Sosa, an immigration judge generally granted a continuance when a respondent had a pending, prima facie approvable U visa petition with USCIS.

The Board now applies the same balancing test from Matter of L-A-B-R- (AG 2018) to U visa continuance requests that already applied to continuances for other pending petitions, such as a family-based I-130. That test weighs primary factors (DHS’s position on the continuance, and whether relief is likely if the petition is granted) and several secondary factors, with no special presumption or accommodation for U visa petitioners based on their status as crime victims.

Every continuance motion must now affirmatively address each primary and secondary factor, with documentation, rather than relying on the petition being prima facie approvable alone. The Board noted a judge can deny a continuance where the underlying visa is only “remotely available,” citing current U visa conditions: more than 433,000 petitions pending with USCIS against an annual statutory cap of 10,000 visas, with final approval often taking seven to ten years or more.

The decision does not change continuances sought for other forms of relief, such as asylum or cancellation of removal; it is limited to continuances based on a pending visa petition or visa availability.

What does this mean?

For attorneys handling U visa cases in removal proceedings: a pending U visa petition alone is no longer likely to be enough to secure a continuance. Build a full record addressing every L-A-B-R- factor for each continuance request, including DHS’s position, the likelihood of eventual relief, and case-specific reasons the continuance is warranted, since the agency’s own backlog data can now cut against a client given current U visa wait times.

For U visa applicants in removal proceedings: having a pending U visa petition does not guarantee your removal case will be paused while USCIS decides it. Talk to your attorney now about what else can support a continuance request, or about other relief that might be available if a continuance is denied.

Bigger picture: this fits directly into the pattern already tracked throughout this roundup series, of the BIA closing off procedural tools, continuances, motions to reopen, bond hearings, that noncitizens have relied on to keep cases open while other relief is pending. Pairing this ruling with record U visa processing delays means the backlog itself is now being used as a reason to deny the very continuance that backlog used to justify.

Sources:

10. USCIS proposes ending deference to its own prior approvals on extension petitions

What happened

DHS published a notice of proposed rulemaking October 14 to remove 8 CFR 214.1(c)(5), the regulation that directs USCIS officers to generally defer to a prior approval when the same employer files an extension petition for the same worker involving the same underlying facts. Comments are due November 13.

This affects extension petitions for nonimmigrant worker categories including H-1B, L-1, and E-2, among others. Today, when nothing material has changed, officers start from a position of deference to the earlier approval. If the rule is finalized as proposed, every extension would instead be evaluated fresh, with no presumption in the petitioner’s favor based on the prior approval alone.

DHS argues removing deference better ensures officers independently verify continued eligibility at each extension, and says the statutory burden of proof belongs on the petitioner, not the agency, regardless of a prior approval. DHS acknowledges this will increase its own operational costs, since officers will spend more time on each extension, and increase costs and uncertainty for petitioners as well.

This proposal already does not apply where there was a material error in the earlier approval, a material change in circumstances, or new information adversely affecting eligibility, deference was never absolute. The change would remove the general presumption that currently applies when none of those exceptions is present.

What does this mean?

For attorneys: treat every H-1B, L-1, E-2, or similar extension filing as a full eligibility case again, not a routine renewal, if this rule takes effect. Build the same evidentiary record for an extension that would be needed for an initial petition, rather than relying on consistency with a prior approval to carry the case.

For employers and workers on these visa categories: an extension that would have been straightforward in the past could face new scrutiny or an RFE even where nothing about the job or the worker’s situation has changed. Budget more time and more complete documentation for extension filings going forward.

Bigger picture: combined with the H-1B fee proposals and the PERM suspensions already covered in this roundup, this continues a pattern of adding friction and cost at every stage of employment-based nonimmigrant status, not just at initial filing, but now at the renewal stage too.

Sources:

11. DHS and DOJ finalize streamlined civil penalty rule, days after a judge blocked the same fines

What happened

DHS and DOJ’s Executive Office for Immigration Review published a final rule October 14 streamlining how DHS imposes civil monetary penalties on three categories of noncitizens: those who willfully fail to depart after a final removal order (up to $998 per day), those who fail to comply with a voluntary departure order (set by an immigration judge or the BIA, generally $1,992 to $9,970), and those found to have entered improperly. The rule finalizes a June 2025 interim rule and does not create new penalties, only new procedures for imposing existing ones.

Under the new procedure, a DHS officer can issue a penalty decision and order directly, without first using the prior Notice of Intent to Fine process. Appeals now go to a supervisory DHS immigration officer on a 15-business-day window, rather than to the BIA, which loses appellate jurisdiction over these penalties entirely. One change from the prior interim rule: DHS will now consider a late-filed appeal on a case-by-case basis if documented mail delivery issues caused the delay.

Nine days earlier, on October 5, U.S. District Judge George A. O’Toole Jr. (D. Mass.) granted preliminary relief in a class action brought by the Legal Aid Society and the Immigrant Legal Resource Center, finding the government’s penalty process under the predecessor interim rule likely violates the Administrative Procedure Act. The court found ICE used boilerplate notices without individually assessing whether a person’s failure to depart was willful, and failed to consider individual circumstances, including that both named plaintiffs were actively pursuing lawful immigration relief. Fines in some cases reached as much as $1.8 million per person, applied retroactively for up to five years. The order halts enforcement of penalties issued under the prior rule since July 27, 2025, while the case continues.

DHS says its broader civil-penalty effort contributed to more than 82,000 departures among people with removal or voluntary departure orders between March 2025 and September 2026, and has issued well over 100,000 penalty notices. An outside analysis found only about 7,700 of those departures involved someone who had actually received a penalty before leaving, suggesting the threat of a fine, more than the fine itself, is driving most of the departures DHS attributes to the program.

What does this mean?

For attorneys: any client with an existing or potential civil penalty under this program should know the legal landscape is genuinely unsettled right now, a court has already found the predecessor version of this penalty process likely unlawful, while DHS has pressed ahead and finalized a new version of essentially the same rule anyway. Document individual circumstances, including any pending application for lawful status, thoroughly for any client facing one of these penalties, since that is precisely what the court found DHS failed to consider.

For noncitizens with a final removal order or voluntary departure order: a large, retroactive fine (potentially hundreds of thousands of dollars or more) is a real possibility if you remain past your departure deadline, even though a court has currently blocked enforcement of fines issued before this rule. Get legal advice before assuming either that the fines are gone for good or that they will definitely be enforced.

Bigger picture: this is a clear example of the government finalizing a rule while litigation over a closely related predecessor version is still active, raising the question of whether the new rule will also be challenged, and whether DHS is betting that a new final rule will be treated as outside the scope of the existing injunction. Watch for a motion to extend that injunction to cover this new rule, or a fresh legal challenge to it directly.

Sources:

12. BIA holds IJs should generally deny asylum for nationals of 40 named “safe” democratic countries

What happened

The BIA ruled October 9 in Matter of B-S-A-N-, 30 I&N Dec. 145 (BIA 2026), that immigration judges should generally deny asylum applications filed by nationals of highly developed, democratic countries that broadly respect and protect human rights, except in extraordinary circumstances involving national security or foreign policy. The Board said pretermission of such claims, deciding the case without a full hearing, is typically appropriate at the master calendar stage.

A footnote in the decision names the covered countries: all 27 European Union member states, plus the United Kingdom, Switzerland, Norway, Iceland, Andorra, Monaco, San Marino, Liechtenstein, Canada, Australia, New Zealand, Japan, and South Korea, roughly 40 countries in total. The Board said this list is based on current conditions and can change if a listed country undergoes significant governmental change or other developments affecting human rights.

Separately, the Board held that nationals of EU member states are presumptively ineligible for a discretionary grant of asylum specifically, reasoning that EU citizenship generally carries the right to live in other EU member states as an alternative to the United States.

The underlying case involved a French national who sought asylum based on fear of Gabonese agents while in France. The Board found it implausible that France, given its effective law enforcement and justice system, would be unable or unwilling to protect her from private persecution, and called asylum claims like hers from similarly situated countries an abuse of the asylum process that wastes adjudicatory resources and delays bona fide refugees. The decision does not categorically bar asylum from these countries, and does not affect withholding of removal or CAT protection, which are not discretionary in the same way.

What does this mean?

For attorneys with clients from any of the roughly 40 listed countries: a standard asylum claim now faces a strong presumption of denial, and the case may be pretermitted as early as the master calendar hearing without a full evidentiary hearing. Build the strongest possible extraordinary-circumstances record from the outset, and evaluate withholding of removal and CAT claims in parallel, since those remain available on their own standards even where discretionary asylum is presumptively denied. Pay particular attention to clients whose risk stems from factors the decision does not address, such as sexual orientation, gender identity, or ethnic minority status within an otherwise “safe” country.

For asylum seekers from a listed country: being a national of one of these countries does not mean you cannot get asylum, but it does mean your case starts from a presumption against you rather than a neutral starting point. Talk to an attorney promptly about whether your specific circumstances fit the extraordinary-circumstances exception, and about other forms of protection that are not affected by this ruling.

Bigger picture: naming specific countries by category, rather than deciding safety case by case, is a significant structural shift, and the list’s current composition will likely draw criticism given that some listed countries have experienced documented human rights concerns for specific minority groups. Watch for litigation challenging the decision’s application to individual cases, and for future BIA or circuit court decisions addressing claims the ruling does not clearly resolve, such as claims based on sexual orientation or ethnicity rather than general country conditions.

Sources:

13. HHS assigns its own government attorneys to represent unaccompanied children, advocates sue over “fast-tracked” cases

What happened

HHS announced October 6, via a Federal Register notice signed by Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr., that it is creating an in-house Unaccompanied Alien Children Legal Representation Division (UACLRD) to directly provide “legal advice and counsel” to unaccompanied migrant children in immigration proceedings. This follows the August contract controversy already covered in this roundup series, and effectively moves children’s legal representation further inside the same federal system that holds them in custody and seeks to remove them.

Critics, including children’s welfare advocates and Senate Democrats led by Sen. Tammy Duckworth, say placing representation inside HHS, the same agency responsible for custody of these children, is an unprecedented conflict of interest that fails basic standards of independent counsel. One advocate quoted by AP said a government-employed attorney would likely be “coached and encouraged” to push a child toward accepting voluntary departure rather than presenting a full case for relief. HHS has not said whether it will continue contracting with outside nonprofit groups or when the new division will be fully operational.

Separately, DHS announced it is now offering unaccompanied migrant children $3,000 to self-deport, a $500 increase over last year’s incentive amount.

In a complaint filed the week of October 16, immigrant advocacy groups sued the administration, alleging new government policies have turned the asylum process for migrant children into what they called a “deportation assembly line” that deprives children of their rights by fast-tracking their asylum cases.

What does this mean?

For attorneys: if you represent unaccompanied children or coordinate with legal aid networks that do, confirm directly with each client or referring organization whether HHS’s new government attorney division is being assigned to any pending case, and flag the conflict of interest clearly to the family and to the court where relevant. Watch the new lawsuit over fast-tracked asylum processing for developments that could affect scheduling and evidentiary expectations in pending children’s cases.

For families of unaccompanied children: a government-employed attorney assigned to your child’s case works for the same federal government seeking to remove your child, not independently for your child alone. You can still seek an independent, private attorney if you are able to, and should ask directly who is representing your child and who that attorney answers to.

Bigger picture: taken together with the August contract story already in this roundup series, this is a continued, significant shift away from independent legal representation for one of the most vulnerable populations in the immigration system, at the same time DHS is financially incentivizing these same children to leave the country voluntarily. The new lawsuit over asylum fast-tracking suggests this entire approach, representation plus accelerated processing plus a self-deportation incentive, is now being challenged as a coordinated scheme rather than separate, unrelated policy choices.

Sources:

14. Immigration judge alleges DOJ ordered her to reverse rulings and run sham bond hearings

What happened

The Washington Post reported October 26 that Karen Donoso Stevens, an immigration judge who served at the Annandale, Virginia Immigration Court since 2016, says a supervisor ordered her in September 2025 to reverse four decisions in which she had granted bond. She says the pressure continued: in November, the head of the immigration court system demanded explanations for six other bond decisions, and in January, another supervisor told her that a court order requiring a bond hearing did not mean she actually had to grant bond. Less than a week after that, on January 14, she was abruptly pulled from her courtroom mid-hearing by a supervisor and reassigned away from detained cases; she was terminated in May 2026, with her termination letter citing Article II of the Constitution without giving a specific reason. Her replacement at Annandale, Richard VanVeldhuisen, has denied about 95% of asylum applications, compared with roughly 85% under Donoso Stevens during this same administration. Donoso Stevens had denied more than half of the asylum applications before her, a record the Post described as consistent with national averages, and had kept pace with her docket and complied with existing quotas. Her account was corroborated by contemporaneous notes and interviews with colleagues, relatives, and private attorneys, according to the Post. Three legal experts the Post consulted all called the alleged conduct an unacceptable infringement of a judge’s decisional independence.

The Justice Department denied that it directs particular outcomes in immigration cases. An EOIR spokesperson told the Post the agency’s approach is to impartially adjudicate cases in accordance with the law and evidence. A separate EOIR statement defended requiring judges to follow precedent, calling the characterization of that as “being told how to rule” partisan and not reflective of how any serious lawyer would view judicial independence.

The report comes after the Justice Department has dismissed roughly 100 of about 700 immigration judges, with the administration replacing some with officials it has called “deportation judges.” Congressional Democrats, including Sens. Chris Van Hollen and Dick Durbin, renewed a push for legislation to remove immigration courts from executive branch control and establish an independent immigration court system, though its prospects remain uncertain.

What does this mean?

For attorneys: this account, if representative of a broader pattern rather than an isolated incident, suggests bond decisions in some courts may reflect pressure from above rather than an individual judge’s independent assessment of the case. Document any bond denial that seems inconsistent with the judge’s own stated findings or with how similar cases have been handled, since that kind of inconsistency could matter in a later appeal or in broader advocacy around this issue.

For noncitizens with a pending bond request: a bond hearing ordered by a court is supposed to result in an independent decision by the judge hearing it, not a predetermined outcome. If you believe your bond hearing did not get a genuine, individualized assessment, discuss this with your attorney as part of any appeal.

Bigger picture: this is a serious, specific allegation of political interference in individual case outcomes, not just a general policy disagreement, and it lands directly on the legitimacy of the bond process that is central to several other items already tracked in this roundup series. Watch for whether other judges come forward with similar accounts, and whether the push for an independent immigration court system gains any real traction in Congress as a result.

Sources:

15. Supreme Court lets stand elimination of administrative closure, immigration judges’ tool for pausing cases

What happened

The Supreme Court declined October 27 to reinstate immigration judges’ authority to use “administrative closure,” a practice judges had used for decades to temporarily pause a deportation case, including when a person had another pending proceeding, such as a visa petition or an appeal of a criminal conviction, that could prevent their removal. The decision came in a one-sentence order with no explanation and no publicly reported dissents.

The Biden administration had codified administrative closure in a 2024 regulation. After returning to office, the Trump administration announced it would no longer defend that regulation, and in June, the administration and the state of Texas jointly asked a federal judge in Wichita Falls, Texas to approve an agreement declaring the regulation unlawful. The judge approved that agreement the same day, blocking administrative closure permanently and nationwide.

Three cities, Baltimore, New Haven, and Columbus, along with the nonprofit legal aid organization Centro Legal de la Raza, asked the Supreme Court for emergency relief to restore administrative closure while the underlying litigation continues. They argued the administration had improperly used what they called “manufactured litigation” with an ideologically aligned state to eliminate a rule it disliked, bypassing the normal federal rulemaking process. The Court denied that request, leaving the elimination of administrative closure in place while the broader case proceeds.

Administrative closure had been applied in hundreds of thousands of deportation cases over the years. Critics of the practice, including Texas and the Trump administration, have argued it functioned as a de facto amnesty by letting people with unresolved status remain in the country indefinitely without a final decision in their case.

What does this mean?

For attorneys: administrative closure is no longer available as a docket management tool anywhere in the country while this litigation continues. Any case strategy that relied on closure while a parallel proceeding, such as a family petition or U visa application, worked its way through the system needs a different approach now, since that case must proceed to a final decision rather than being paused.

For noncitizens with a case that might otherwise have been administratively closed: your removal case will need to move toward a final decision even if you have another immigration matter pending elsewhere that could eventually help you. Talk to your attorney promptly about what options remain, such as a continuance request or seeking termination on other grounds, since closure itself is off the table for now.

Bigger picture: this removes a docket tool that was central to how immigration courts managed cases involving overlapping proceedings for decades, adding more pressure to a system already strained by the compressed hearing schedules and narrowed continuance standards covered elsewhere in this roundup series. The underlying legal fight over whether the government properly used a settlement with a friendly state to eliminate a federal regulation is still ongoing, so this result could change if the broader case is eventually decided differently.

Sources:

16. Fifth Circuit rules en banc that detained noncitizens have no constitutional right to a bond hearing

What happened

The full Fifth Circuit ruled 10-7 on October 23 that the Fifth Amendment’s due process protections do not require bond hearings for immigration detainees. The cases involved two Mexican citizens and one Honduran citizen.

Judge Cory Wilson wrote for the majority that detained noncitizens are not constitutionally entitled to proceedings beyond what Congress provided by statute, and that anyone seeking freedom from physical restraint can achieve it by agreeing to leave the country. Judge Dana Douglas dissented, warning that unchecked executive power to arrest and detain indefinitely “echoes fearfully from history.”

The en banc court reversed course from a July panel ruling, decided 2-1, that held ICE could not detain people beyond 90 days without a bond hearing. A February Fifth Circuit ruling had already adopted the government’s reading of the mandatory detention statute.

The Supreme Court agreed this month to hear the mandatory detention question, but that review covers only whether the statute requires bond hearings, not whether the Constitution does.

What does this mean?

For attorneys: in Texas, Louisiana, and Mississippi, a constitutional due process argument for a bond hearing is now foreclosed at the circuit level, leaving habeas petitions dependent on statutory arguments. Preserve the constitutional claim for further review, and track the Supreme Court’s statutory decision closely, since it will not resolve the constitutional question.

For detained noncitizens in the Fifth Circuit: a federal court is no longer likely to order a bond hearing on due process grounds, even after prolonged detention. Families should consult an attorney quickly about any remaining release options.

Bigger picture: the Fifth Circuit now stands firmly on the government’s side of the split over mandatory detention. The Supreme Court case from item 1 is the next major development, but its narrower scope means the constitutional question may stay open.

Sources:

17. Civil rights groups sue DHS and USCIS over “Unlawful Voter Initiative” targeting naturalized citizens

What happened

OCA-Asian Pacific American Advocates, OCA-San Mateo, OCA-Sacramento, and Common Cause sued DHS and USCIS in federal court on October 28. They are represented by the ACLU Voting Rights Project, Asian Americans Advancing Justice-AAJC, the ACLU of Northern California, the ACLU of Southern California, and Asian Americans Advancing Justice Southern California.

The lawsuit challenges the “Unlawful Voter Initiative,” a USCIS program the plaintiffs say has operated since August 2026. According to the complaint as described by the ACLU, federal agents rely on outdated, error-prone data and pose as individual voters to search private voter registration records on state election websites. The plaintiffs allege thousands of naturalized citizens have faced improper investigations, door-to-door interrogations, and possible disenfranchisement.

The plaintiffs allege violations of the Civil Rights Act’s Uniform Standards Provision, the Privacy Act, and the Administrative Procedure Act.

They ask the court to stop DHS and USCIS from continuing the initiative, to block the federal government from pressuring state election officials to withhold or discard valid ballots cast by people on DHS’s lists, and to declare the initiative unlawful.

What does this mean?

For attorneys: naturalized citizens contacted by USCIS or DHS agents about voter eligibility may need advice on whether to speak with agents, and on how to document the contact. Counsel should also confirm that a client’s voter registration records and naturalization records are accurate and consistent.

For naturalized citizens: a visit or call from federal agents about voter registration is not a reason to answer questions without counsel. Naturalized citizens who are contacted should consult an attorney before responding.

Bigger picture: the case tests whether DHS can use immigration databases to investigate the voting eligibility of citizens, and it follows the broader trend of immigration agencies taking on enforcement roles outside traditional immigration matters. The court has not ruled, and the allegations are the plaintiffs’ account of the program.

Sources:

18. Legal services groups sue ICE for removing detainees with final removal orders from its online locator

What happened

Four legal services organizations, including Greater Boston Legal Services, sued in federal court in Boston on October 28 to challenge an ICE policy adopted in September. ICE removed the locations of people with final removal orders from its Online Detainee Locator System and told staff not to reveal where they are held.

As of September, the change affected more than 16,000 of the nearly 69,000 people in ICE custody. About 1.4 million people in the United States are subject to final removal orders. Lawyers report spending significantly more time tracking down clients.

The plaintiffs allege the change violates the Administrative Procedure Act because ICE adopted it without explanation, and violates the First Amendment because it impedes lawyers’ ability to advise people of their rights and to reach prospective clients. They ask the court to block the change.

ICE and DHS have not publicly confirmed the change. They say they prioritize people with final removal orders for deportation, deny disappearing detainees, and say detainees can still make phone calls. A DHS statement said: “The appropriate process due to an illegal alien with final deportation orders is removal, plain and simple.”

What does this mean?

For attorneys: a client or family member with a final order may not appear in the ICE locator even when detained. Call the ICE field office, check with the local detention facilities, and file a request for the client’s location in writing as early as possible. Keep records of each attempt to locate a client, since they may support a habeas petition or a motion to stay removal.

For families of people with final removal orders: if a detained family member cannot be found in the online locator, that does not mean the person was released. Contact an attorney and the local ICE office right away.

Bigger picture: the policy reduces the ability of lawyers and families to reach people at the point when time-sensitive filings matter most, and it fits the broader pattern of limited transparency around detention covered in this roundup series. The court has not ruled.

Sources:

Go Back

Immigration Law & Policy Roundup – October 2026

Read more :

Aug 5, 2026

Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) Requests for Immigration Cases

Request Your File and Protect Your Case
Read More
Changes to F-1 and J-1 Visa Status: What You Need to Know

Sep 11, 2026

Changes to F-1 and J-1 Visa Status: What You Need to Know

Read More

Dec 24, 2025

New USCIS Policies Impacting Asylum Applicants, Refugees, and People from “High-Risk” Countries

Read More
Domestic Travel Information for Green Card Holders

Aug 5, 2026

Domestic Travel Information for Green Card Holders

Read More